From a question in comments to the previous post today.
In order:
First Tier
1. The ACEP First Aid Manual Start here. PERIOD.
2a. Wilderness Medicine: Beyond First Aid, Forgey
2b. The Prepper's Medical Handbook, Forgey
3. Special Operations Forces Medical Handbook
4. Survival Medicine Handbook, Alton and Alton
5. Auerbach's Wilderness Medicine (2 vol.)
7a. Where There Is No Doctor *Medical care for the Turd World, but that may be you someday.
7b. Where There Is No Dentist *One of the only texts I know of that deals with dental care under austere circumstances.
Honorable Mentions:
The entire medical section in the classic SAS Survival Handbook.
Also, any Red Cross medical handbook from before 1960, solely for the sections on bandaging and splinting, which cover techniques that still hold up, and are no longer covered by anyone currently. Forget anything from that era having to do with snakebite treatment, or whatever CPR was called then, but the bandaging and splinting techniques, though old, are just as good now as they were then, and you won't find them easily too many other places.
Secondary
There are a ton of second-tier texts out there, seldom actually bad, but not anywhere near the same league as the above texts. If your favorite isn't listed above, bummer. I've seen a lot of books that are okay, but the ones I named above are comprehensive, and good. You can do worse, but you won't do better.
You may find some utility in military medical manuals, for some purposes. Other than the two I mention last, there may frequently be found some utility in learning geared towards someone who dropped out in 9th grade, working in Turd World conditions. As long as the text isn't pre-Vietnam, you might get your hands on something worthwhile in some aspects. But check anything found against the comprehensive and modern references listed at the top of this post first.
The next level is actual medical texts, used by doctors, if you have a licensed practitioner (MD, PA, RN) in your midst.
The go-to for my career field is Tintinalli's Emergency Medicine Handbook.
2160 pages, $189, and geared for an ER doc with access to Xrays, ultrasound, CT scanners, MRIs, plus a lab and a pharmacy. But still how residents learn how to do ED medicine.
Other good choices would be a nursing pharmacology handbook, and standard medical manuals on primary care and diagnosis, orthopedics, an atlas of skin disorders, and on and on.
Anything beyond primary and preventative care is either going to require definitive treatment beyond what you can do yourself (which you may or may not have access to), or your patient(s) are going to have problems ranging from chronic to terminal. You're not going to solve surgical problems, most infectious diseases, major burns, or most critical traumas, because you don't have the resources to do much beyond initial stabilization, which assumes access to secondary and tertiary care.
Which means if you're beyond access to 1st world care, including anesthesia, antibiotics, and general pharmacy needs, like you will be in extreme circumstances - people will die, including those nearest and dearest to you, and you can't prevent that.
So mortuary texts on handling bodies, prevention of outbreaks after people die (potentially with infectious diseases), and strong disinfectants, aren't a bad idea. Burial and cremation activities become more important as life spans shorten, in austere circumstances.
Bottom Of The Barrel
Books that are mostly a complete waste of time and money, except as historical reference:
Special Forces Medical Handbook ST 31-91 (1982) - any version
50 years out of date, this is about as currently useless as medical texts from the Civil War, or ancient Greece. If you want to learn things from 1982, go ahead on. After you're completely fluent in the first ten or so books at the top of this post. In your ample spare time.
If you're a doctor, you know better medical texts. And if you aren't one, you aren't going to be doing anything in this book, and if you do, your patient will die. Either screaming, or from the inevitable infection from trying to do 21st century surgery under 17th century conditions. Just...don't.
We're not trying to get you through medical school here, just get you up to speed on fundamentals of primary care, both in the field, and in an off-grid (short-term or longer) situation.
Get all the knowledge and experience you can now, while it's both cheap, and easily available.
When you're 5000 miles from help up Schitt's Creek, or in a Turd World/Civil War era medical situation, it's too late to crack a friggin' book, or take a class.
For me, the real utility of Where There Is No Doctor is the 'green pages' in the back with drug usage/dosage. It seems like it would come in handy when youre scavenging through the remains of a looted ambulance or Walgreens and need to know whats worth taking and why.
ReplyDeleteThat, and a teaching medical aid for people barely up to the task.
DeleteI've seen recent Common Core grads, and for the last 20 years or so, they're closer to Turd World pupils from Nigeria or Amazon native tribes than they are to modern students in a STEM program, 9 days out of every week. But they can be improved, with baby steps. ;)
Good work Aesop. Same comment for your Aid bag earlier.
ReplyDeleteYou have good taste in music, and good advice in medicine.
Pity most will wait like your family member in the Aid bag article until the "zon" isn't working well anymore.
Darwinism works.
You might want to check this one out...
ReplyDeleteREMOTE, AUSTERE, WILDERNESS & THIRD WORLD MEDICINE
Welcome to the REMOTE, AUSTERE, WILDERNESS & THIRD WORLD MEDICINE.
An interesting find from Miss Daisy's house... the 1967 Boy Scouts of America field book. It has a LOT of info (basic splinting and 'stuff' you mentioned which is NOT taught any longer) but ALSO has 'field sanitation' the "How tos and How Not tos" (how far/deep and safe is your 'cat hole' and such) as well as interesting basic fishing/gathering/hunting/skinning info all in one very useful book.
ReplyDeleteGranted it's older than me, but a LOT of that stuff is no longer covered ANYWHERE and was the go-to 'back in the day' for what a scout was supposed to know how to do at a -bare minimum-.
I've seen it on eBay and in used book stores for VERY short $$$
Mine was older brother's handbook for boys, from about 1955. Same bandaging and splinting info that Red Cross used to teach, before they dumbed down first aid to "slap a bandage on, and dial 9-1-1". With, as you noted, pretty good info for all the other things you need to get along in the backcountry, when they were still something worth participating in, long before they became the go-to pedophile grooming organization, and then the Fabulous Ghey Rainbow Hippie Scouts.
DeleteTintinalli or Rosen...
ReplyDeleteI'd throw in a professional medical dictionary...My go-to is Stedman but there are other choices (Ford/Chevy/Dodge style)
The ST-31-91 is good only for camp craft and maybe vet medicine. It was a compilation of Vietnam era SF medics remembrances from their training: Mostly old wives tales... Not actual validated medical information.
But everyone focuses on trauma. More lives will be saved with boring, routine hygiene than anything else. What do you do when the toilet stops flushing? How do you purify mass quantities of water? Dispose of trash and garbage safely?
This is why the military manual entitled Field Sanitation And Hygiene is da bomb. Digging latrines and purifying water hasn't changed much in 100 years.
DeleteWhat is your opinion of The Merck Manual along side of a good drug book?
ReplyDeleteSuz
Which one? :)
DeleteThere are a half-dozen "Merck Manuals".
I have three of them, all different.
But if you mean the pharmacopaeia, it's the gold standard drug reference book, but for most people, it's way too inside-baseball, with information about 10x more detailed than you want or need, unless you're in the trade.
IOW, if you're a doctor, you probably already have one. If you're not, you probably don't need one.
You're better off with a Mosby or similar Nursing drug reference, which will give you pharma news you can use, to a level much easier for lay persons to grasp and follow.
I wouldn't throw one away, but I wouldn't go out of my way to get a new one, unless you find a last year's edition for sale cheap at a yard or book sale.
A new one goes for $73. You can find the next-to-last edition for sale for $5-$10 if you dig around. If that happens, it's worth putting one on the shelf.
The Merck Manual of diagnosis and treatment is not especially useful to the layperson. If you have the drugs, great. If you have the surgical skills, great. If you have both you won't need it.
DeleteThank you.
ReplyDeleteI need to pick up the last Wilderness Medicine set. A friend of mine and I helped Paul flesh out a section of the original and I still have the copy he sent. I think he was still with Vanderbilt at the time but may have gone on to Stanford by the time Elsevier got it out.
ReplyDeleteSucked when he caught the same bug my girl did in 2020 - we got 4 years and he only got 11 months...
Another one I have gotten a lot of use out of over the years - probably out of your usual area - Medicine for Mountaineering / Wilkerson
I also like the stuff from Doc Forgey - was a very nice conversation when he was though here on a book tour years ago
I've got Wilkerson's book too, but it's not as good as Forgey or Auerbach.
DeleteHey Aesop,
ReplyDeleteI'm by no means a doctor. Just a guy that learned a lot in 6 decades. Basic first aid, red cross certified multiple times and lots of injuries and wounds of my own and close kin and closer friends over the years.
Being on a retiree budget and all, in what order would you get those books to maximize bang for buck?
1. Then either 2a or 2b. Then 4. 3. 6. 5. Whichever 2 (a or b) you didn't get first. 7b. 7a.
DeleteCost being a factor, do it that way. If you had to stop at only two or three texts, you'd still be way ahead of 95% of everyone if you did it that way.
Another good medical reference is Grey’s anatomy and the 1940’s E Lily reprint of De Medica. De Medica has a great appendix with how to run labs for hospital/Dr office De Medica turns up on ebay and I think there is a pdf somewhere I found a copy and it’s in my First Aid tub with Grey’s Anatomy
ReplyDeleteThere are too many commemorative copies of Grey's Anatomy floating around - with bad information from old editions. The old physiology is especially bad. Be certain to get a current, serious textbook.
DeleteA better Anatomy is Netter's Anatomy (the standard in US medical schools). Either way remember that nobody is assembled from blueprints, identically. Things may be in somewhat different places than you expect - this is why students slice up cadavers in medical school - to see the differences. Otherwise they'd just look at pictures in a book.
^That.
DeleteGet a real anatomy text if you're in the market.
A couple of more books to consider: "Improvised Medicine" 2nd, Isserson. Expensive, but has some good ideas for getting by with less. Borrow it, get a used copy, it's not worth $120 but is good.
ReplyDeleteAnd "Anesthesia Off the Grid", by Li, MD.
Throwing this in the mix "The Ship's Medicine Chest and Medical Aid at Sea".
ReplyDeleteAnd if you have the time/interest/motivation, hit up your local CC and take a course in medical terminology; usually can be done remotely and not too much $$$. Goes a long way in understanding what you're trying to work on & if you have to interact with 'the professionals', using med language improves communications..
Have it. Read it. Not impressed.
DeleteIt's second-tier.